- Deployment Model:
SAP SuccessFactors: Primarily cloud based, with options for hybrid deployment, integrated with other SAP tools.
Workday: Fully cloud based SaaS, designed for regular updates without dedicated infrastructure needs.
PeopleSoft: Traditionally on premises, with some cloud hosted options; heavily relies on IT for maintenance.
- Core HR and HCM Functionality:
SAP SuccessFactors: Comprehensive suite covering Core HR, payroll, talent management, and learning; integrates well with SAP ERP.
Workday: Advanced HCM capabilities, including talent and performance management.
PeopleSoft: Strong HR, payroll, and benefits administration, with high configurability.
- Talent Management:
SAP SuccessFactors: Full suite including recruiting, on boarding, and performance management.
Workday: User friendly talent management tools for performance tracking and development.
PeopleSoft: Solid features but may require more customization.
- Payroll and Benefits:
SAP SuccessFactors: Localized payroll with third party integrations for non SAP users.
Workday: Mainly payroll for U.S., Canada, U.K., and France; third party integration available.
PeopleSoft: Strong payroll capabilities for large organizations; highly configurable.
- User Interface and Experience:
SAP SuccessFactors: Modern UI, though complexity can be a drawback.
Workday: Intuitive, user friendly interface that appeals to employees.
PeopleSoft: Traditional UI with improvements for mobile access.
- Reporting and Analytics:
SAP SuccessFactors: Strong reporting with embedded analytics.
Workday: Builtin analytics for real time insights.
PeopleSoft: Powerful reporting but requires setup for advanced analytics.
- Integrations:
SAP SuccessFactors: Seamless integration with SAP products.
Workday: Easy integration with third party systems.
PeopleSoft: Best with Oracle products, requiring more custom development for others.
- Customization and Flexibility:
SAP SuccessFactors: Highly customizable but can be time consuming.
Workday: Less customizable, but extensive configurability is available.
PeopleSoft: Extremely customizable, requiring significant IT resources.
- Cost Structure:
SAP SuccessFactors: Subscription based, modular pricing.
Workday: Subscription model with regular updates; costs may increase based on modules.
PeopleSoft: Higher upfront costs with ongoing maintenance fees.
- Ideal Use Cases:
SAP SuccessFactors: Large enterprises needing indepth HR capabilities.
Workday: Companies seeking a user friendly, cloud native solution.
PeopleSoft: Large organizations needing highly customized solutions.